Текст - полностью, я лишь упустила оценки типа такого:
OVERALL EVALUATION: -2 (reject) REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 3 (medium) Paper Classification: 1 (review paper / state of the art report) Originality / Novelty: 2 (poor) Importance, Utility: 3 (fair) Use of English Language: 2 (poor) Completeness & Correctness of References: 3 (fair) Suitability for VS-Games: 2 (poor) If this submission is rejected in its current form, could it be accepted at a lower category?: 2 (accept as a poster) Conformance to IEEE conference submissions.: 3 (correctly formatted) If accepted, should this paper be invited for resubmission to a journal?: 3 (No) If accepted, should this paper be considered for the Best IEEE Member Paper award, if one of its authors is an IEEE member?: 1 (no)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2015-06-06 09:56 am (UTC)OVERALL EVALUATION: -2 (reject)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 3 (medium)
Paper Classification: 1 (review paper / state of the art report)
Originality / Novelty: 2 (poor)
Importance, Utility: 3 (fair)
Use of English Language: 2 (poor)
Completeness & Correctness of References: 3 (fair)
Suitability for VS-Games: 2 (poor)
If this submission is rejected in its current form, could it be accepted at a lower category?: 2 (accept as a poster)
Conformance to IEEE conference submissions.: 3 (correctly formatted)
If accepted, should this paper be invited for resubmission to a journal?: 3 (No)
If accepted, should this paper be considered for the Best IEEE Member Paper award, if one of its authors is an IEEE member?: 1 (no)